You have no items in your shopping cart.
Copied article link.

Why Narcissistic Leaders Don’t Like Remote Work

Picture of Why Narcissistic Leaders Don’t Like Remote Work

Maybe your boss is resistant to remote work because they’re worried about trust, collaboration, and office culture.

Or maybe they’re just a narcissist.

A new study from Wharton management professor Adam Grant and doctoral candidates Marissa Shandell and Courtney Elliott finds that the biggest common denominator of leaders who oppose remote work is a big ego. Simply put, narcissistic leaders like to throw their weight around, and they need employees in the room in order to do that.

“Narcissism was the only trait that we found that consistently predicted resistance to remote work,” Shandell said. “Leaders who had narcissistic qualities were the most likely to resist remote work, and that was driven by their desire for power and status.”

The aptly titled paper, “Worship Me at the Office Altar: Why Narcissistic Leaders Resist Remote Work,” appears in the journal Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. The authors also recently published an essay about it in The New York Times that has garnered more than 2,000 comments.

It’s no surprise that it’s a hot topic. Remote work went from being the “new normal,” with estimates of 40% to 70% of American workers fully remote or hybrid during the COVID-19 pandemic, to the current rate of about 22%. The scholars were curious about the decline, especially when the available data showed that remote employees maintained the same or higher productivity levels and higher levels of personal satisfaction.

“The brute-force push back to the office didn’t align with what we were seeing about well-being and performance,” Shandell said. “We were picking up on trust as a main issue, but we felt there was an incomplete part of the story about how leaders were forced to change the way they operated during remote work.”

“Narcissism was the only trait that we found that consistently predicted resistance to remote work.”— Marissa Shandell

 

The scholars theorized that narcissism is a critical reason for the return to office, because narcissistic leaders cannot fulfill their desire for power, status, and agency in a remote setting. They can’t hover over cubicles, pound their fists on a conference table, or stare people down to establish their dominance, they said. Instead, bosses are left staring at tiny video squares often filled with facial expressions of boredom or indifference. “Sycophantic reassurances from employees just don’t have the same effect if they’re on Slack,” the scholars wrote in The Times.

CEO Photo Size as a Measure of Ego

Shandell, Elliott, and Grant devised three separate studies — an analysis, a survey, and an experiment — to test their hypotheses. Each study was designed to build on the previous one, starting with an archival analysis of 259 chief executive officers of Fortune 500 companies. They examined publicly available data about them, including news articles in which they expressed opinions about remote work, annual reports, and statements. They also observed the prominence of the CEO’s photograph in the company’s annual report, the size of their signature, and their cash and non-cash compensation compared with the second-highest paid executive at the firm — all proxy indicators of ego.

The results of the three studies showed a consistent pattern. Narcissistic CEOs resisted remote work more intensely and expressed a wider range of rejections to it. That resistance was explained by power and status motivation, and not by a lack of trust in their employees.

“The public discourse was about trust and leaders wanting their employees back because of trust. We knew there was more to the story given we’re in an era of digital monitoring,” Shandell said.

She and her co-authors emphasize that the causality flows in one direction: Not every leader who resists remote work is narcissistic, but narcissistic leaders are the ones who most resist remote work.

“We know that leaders can be egotistical, which can drive people to do things that people without egos won’t do,” Elliott said.

“We know that leaders can be egotistical, which can drive people to do things that people without egos won’t do.”— Courtney Elliott

 

Setting Egos Aside to Make Hybrid Work

Return-to-office mandates are happening across the U.S., led by some of the biggest CEOs including Andy Jassy of Amazon, Jamie Dimon of JPMorgan Chase, Mark Zuckerberg of Meta, Bob Iger of Disney, and even President Donald Trump. In January 2025, he signed an executive order requiring all 2.9 million federal employees to return to in-person work five days a week.

Despite the downward trend, the scholars believe the hybrid model isn’t going to disappear. Flexibility is key to recruiting and retaining top talent.

“I think remote work is here to stay,” Shandell said. “Increasingly, companies will experiment and learn how to make it work for them. The best-case scenario is we will see more flexibility brought to this topic.”

To that end, the scholars offer four research-based guidelines to help managers “put their egos aside and master the art of managing from afar.”

  1. Have anchor days where everyone shows up. This especially helps newcomers and junior staffers who need mentoring.
  2. Intensity beats frequency. The right kinds of interactions can forge more meaningful connections than just showing up in the office daily.
  3. Hybrid work is not one-size-fits-all. Parity is a common complaint among employees at the same firm where some can work remotely while others cannot. But Elliott said it’s similar to having people at the same company filling different roles and earning different salaries, or a different number of vacation days. “Corporate policies are rarely one-size-fits-all,” she said.
  4. When is more important than where. If employers can’t or won’t offer remote days, there are other ways to give employees some autonomy, including a flexible schedule.

And lastly, the scholars have some advice for employees who want to ask their narcissistic boss for a hybrid schedule: Don’t threaten their power and status.

“Instead of advocating assertively for remote work, it may be more prudent to consult leaders for their advice on what would make hybrid arrangements palatable,” they wrote in the paper. “By showing respect for their authority and accomplishments, employees may provide narcissistic leaders with validation and reduce their resistance.”


This article appeared in Knowledge at Wharton (https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/why-narcissistic-leaders-dont-like-remote-work/).
Copied article link.